You can also drop off your payment to our agency and we will take care of it for you. Be sure to make

the payment in our agency at least one day before the cancellation date if you have a cancellation notice.

TRAVELERS

Download the MyTravelers Mobile App for quick self-service options such as the ability to pay bills, download insurance cards, request and track roadside assistance, file and track the status of a claim, etc.

 

CLICK HERE TO view your policy, pay your bill or view claims

Claims
1-800-CLAIM33
Check the status of your claim

 

For ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE, call 1-800-252-4633


Send payments to:
Travelers Personal Insurance
PO Box 660307
Dallas, TX 75266-0307

KEMPER

Manage My Policy Login

Billing Inquiry

1-800-437-8394

Make A Payment Online

 

To make a claim, call 1-888-252-2799, Option 4
or follow the link to make a claim online

CLICK HERE for Online Claim Information

 

For 24/7 ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE, call 1-855-849-3858 

Contact towing@kemper.com to submit receipts for reimbursement if you had service from another provider

Send payments to:
Kemper
PO Box 550750
Jacksonville, FL 32255

MERCHANTS

CLICK HERE TO view your policy & pay bills online

Claims
1-800-952-5246 - 8am to 7pm
1-800-235-6304 (FAX)

1-877-446-0431 Glass Claims Safelite Solutions

After Hours Emergency Claims
1-888-644-6680

Billing Inquiry
1-800-462-8182

For credit card payments, call: 1-800-852-4052

 

For ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE, call 1-866-328-5771

 

Be sure to download the Merchants Insurance Group app, which is available through the app store.

The app allows you to download your ID cards directly to your phone among many other useful things.


Send payments to:
Merchants Insurance Group
Direct Bill Department
PO Box 4031
Buffalo, NY 14240-4031
 

MAIN STREET AMERICA

CLICK HERE TO view the company website

CLICK HERE TO view policyholder services

 

Billing
Pay Your Bill Online


Claims Department 24/7
To make a claim, call 1-877-425-2467 or Report Your Claim Online

Send payments to:
The Main Street America Group
P.O. Box 2004
Keene, N.H. 03431

(800) 611-0958

NEW YORK STATE

INSURANCE FUND

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website or pay your bill

General Information
(631) 756-4000

Certificates
Call (631)756-4132 or sign up to create your own certificates online

Claims

CLICK HERE FOR more information on claims

 

CLICK HERE TO Find Information On Processed Benefit Payments For Either Workers’ Compensation or Disability Benefits 

Send payments to:
8 Corporate Center Drive
2nd Floor
Melville, NY 11747

PRINCIPAL

CLICK HERE FOR claims

 

CLICK HERE FOR customer login

CLICK HERE to pay life or disability policies

Call 1-800-986-3343 with any questions or concerns.

PROGRESSIVE

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website - Register Now
This is a complete service website allowing you to change your car, change your address, check your payments, etc.

CLICK HERE for Claims or call 1-800-776-4737

For ROADSIDE ASSISTANCE, call 1-800-776-2778

CLICK HERE for Customer Service or call 1-800-776-4737
Billing Questions
Pay Your Bill Online


Payments: Use the return envelope you received with your bill. If you do not have a bill, send payments to:
Progressive
PO Box 94618
Cleveland, OH 44101
Attn: In Mail (make sure your policy number is on the check).

METLIFE

Register for eService
CLICK HERE TO view your policy, billing & claims

Claims
1-800-854-6011
Report Glass Claim ONLINE or call the number above.

Customer Service / Make a Payment by Credit Card
1-800-422-4272

Send payments to:
METLIFE Auto & Home
PO Box 41753
Philadelphia, PA 19101-1753

OCEAN HARBOR CASUALTY

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website

 

Billing
Pay Your Bill Online

Claims Department
To make a claim, call 1-855-585-0500 or follow this link to Report Your Claim Online & select 'Claim Info' in the upper right menu

Send payments to:
Ocean Harbor Casualty Insurance Company

7 High Street Suite 408
Huntington, NY 11743

(631)547-5959

PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSURANCE

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website

 

Billing
Pay Your Bill Online


Claims Department
To make a claim, call 1-844-208-1933 or follow this link to Report Your Claim Online 

Claims Email: NYClaims@plymouthrock.com

Send payments to:

Plymouth Rock NY
PO BOX 55940
Boston, MA 02205-5940

(844) 208-1935

NARRAGANSETT BAY

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website

 

Billing Support 1-800-343-3375, Option 3
Pay Your Bill Online


Claims Department
To make a claim, call 1-800-343-3375 or follow this link to Report Your Claim Online 

Claims Email: claimsmail@nbic.com

Send payments to:

Narragansett Bay Insurance Company

C/O Bank of Tampa

P.O. Box 31317

Tampa, FL 33631

SHELTERPOINT

CLICK HERE TO visit the company website

CLICK HERE TO access your account online

Claims

Fax 516-504-6414
Contact claims@shelterpoint.com with any questions or concerns

Customer Service

Fax 516-504-6436
Contact customerservice@shelterpoint.com with any questions or concerns

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Google Maps

27 Pine Hollow Road - Oyster Bay - NY 11771-0630 - 516.922.9131
Copyright ©2016, OysterBayInsurance.com. All Rights Reserved.

Please find our Privacy Policy here.