An independent insurance agency

We are a three generation, family run independent insurance agency established in 1979. We represent several national & regional insurance companies as either agents or brokers. Whatever your insurance needs, we will be happy to provide you a no cost, no obligation comparison and review of your insurance. We invite your inquiries.

Protect Yourself From the Unexpected

What you can expect with Oyster Bay Insurance:

  • Selection of the company or companies best suited to your situation.

  • Honesty and fairness in all our dealings.

  • Dependable, complete service and our availability to answer your questions.



Taking Care of Your Needs


Ready for Anything

Fund managers team consultation and disc



Protecting You


For peace of mind



Unparalleled Insurance Services

There's no doubt that buying insurance can be a complicated and challenging task - and the first and most important consideration of the process is deciding exactly how to make your purchase. If you choose to work with a Trusted Choice Independent Insurance Agent, you're getting a licensed professional capable of offering customized coverage from a broad range of major, proven insurance providers. ‘Customized’ means that we will tailor a solution that meets your specific needs and budget, to accommodate what you can afford while assuring protection for what you value most. As time goes on (and it will !), your needs evolve. We’re here to help as your insurance needs change. As your independent agent, we’ll always be ready to provide a comprehensive review of your coverage and recommend adjustments along the way. As members of your community, your well being, and that of your family, is important to us. Stop by to see us anytime.


To speak with one of our agents, please call our agency Monday-Friday between 8:30am and 4:30pm.

For your convenience, you may also reach us by fax or send us a message in the space provided.

27 Pine Hollow Rd, P.O. Box 630, 

Oyster Bay, NY 11771

Tel: (516) 922-9131

Fax: (516) 922-9014


Fill out a quote sheet below and fax or email it to us for review! We will then give you a call with any questions we have,

  • Lara Bousleiman

    We've been insuring our home and cars with the OBI team for over 16 years now, and they have been most reliable and efficient, and what I value most is their personalized support at anytime! Highly recommend this awesome team!

  • Lisa Hansen

    A wonderful family business to handle our insurance needs. Janet offered a combo package of home and auto which saved us money. Great personal service when I was having a problem with my windshield,  and good recommendations to handle roof issues as well. Nice to have this personal service you don't typically see from insurance companies. Highly recommended!

  • Paulette Palumbo

    We have been clients for many years. Everyone at Oyster Bay, especially Janet, has always been there to offer suggestions, as well as help with all of our insurance problems and decisions. They are easy to reach and deal with you on a personal level! We highly recommend Oyster Bay Insurance.

  • Axel Yberg

    I'm beyond thrilled with the quality of service and personal attention that I receive from Oyster Bay Insurance. Time and time again, they make the effort to ensure that I'm getting the best value for my money and the proper coverage that is best suited for my needs. I can recommend them with the utmost confidence.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Google Maps

27 Pine Hollow Road - Oyster Bay - NY 11771-0630 - 516.922.9131
Copyright ©2016, OysterBayInsurance.com. All Rights Reserved.

Please find our Privacy Policy here.